So forgiveness pre-requires understanding the mistakes of the past? here hear re this opposing this me-first, America-first, white-first, male-first approach>…
Lesson 13: God’s Passion
•
•
comments

Comments
One response to “Lesson 13: God’s Passion”
-
The early theologians, such as John and Paul, presented the Cross as an act of God’s love without trying to explain it theologically. It was not until Anselm in the 11th century that the Penal Substitution Theory appears in its fullness. We hear it cited a lot now days. A crude popular take is that God’s Law must be fulfilled. Disobedience to it raises God’s Wrath that cannot be satisfied unless a price is paid for sin. Jesus takes the punishment and pays the penalty we deserve.
It should be easy to see this separates Father and Son. This misuse of the Trinity makes the Father a child abuser. In addition, God serves the law rather than v.v.
In the 12th century Abelard presented “The Moral Influence Theory” that maintains Jesus’s death produces a life-changing response in us. We are inspired when we hear about Jesus standing for Truth even in the face of death. God captures our hearts, so that we want to do his will. The problem with this one is it usually comes off as being little different from any other self-sacrificing act of love.
The third classical theory is Luther’s 16th century understanding that Jesus’ death is a victory over sin and evil. Luther could describe this as Christ descending to hell where he overcomes the power of Satan. Usually the emphasis is on God freeing us from slavery to sin.
All three of these classical theories are built on previous attempts to explain the Crucifixion. All offer some insight, but none alone suffices to explain the atonement, the change in relationship between God and humanity that takes place in Jesus’ Crucifixion and Resurrection.
Leave a Reply
Recent Comments
An extremely timely topic. Thanks, Fritz!
yes we need to forgive our leaders yet make sure they do the right thing – which they aren’t.
More posts
-

Lesson 1: The Reading Groups
Read more: Lesson 1: The Reading GroupsMany years ago my daughter and son-in-law asked me to lead a reading group for a few high school students. Before long it became apparent many more were interested in discussing their faith seriously. At…
-

Lesson 2: Speaking For God
Read more: Lesson 2: Speaking For GodAll three of our youth groups are very troubled with those claiming to speak for God when uttering hate messages. Twice during the last year the High School Reading Group wanted to talk about Westboro…
-

Lesson 3: Ben Laden’s Assasination
Read more: Lesson 3: Ben Laden’s AssasinationBob is quite right when he warns that our response to the actions of those we oppose too often plays into their hands. You see this in many of our reactions to 9/11. All three…
